Story :Straitlaced Princeton University admissions officer Portia Nathan is caught off-guard when she makes a recruiting visit to an alternative high school overseen by her former classmate, the freewheeling John Pressman. Pressman has surmised that Jeremiah, his gifted yet very unconventional student, might well be the son that Portia secretly gave up for adoption many years ago.
Cast
Tina FeyPortia Nathan
Ann HaradaMrs. Lafont
Ben LevinJunior Lafont
Dan LevyJames
Maggie Keenan-BolgerGirl on Tour
Gloria ReubenCorinne
Paul RuddJohn Pressman
Wallace ShawnClarence
Elaine KussackAbby
Christopher Evan WelchBrandt
Michael GenadryBen
Juliet BrettPraying Applicant
John BrodskySmug Kid
Camille BrantonGymnast
Sarita ChoudhuryRachael
Michael SheenMark
Ken BarnettAdmissions Counselor
Nat WolffJeremiah
Travis BrattenQuest Student
Tanisha LongQuest Student
Nadia AlexanderQuest Student
Karen PhamQuest Student
Travaris SpearsNelson
Lily TomlinSusannah
Rob CampbellRichard
Sonya WalgerHelen
Olek KrupaPolokov
Roby SobieskiMakeout Guy
Lauren SchaffelStudent at Party
Brian Charles JohnsonStudent at Party
Lipica ShahStudent at Party
Jarod EinsohnKeg Guy
Caliaf St. AubynKeg Guy's Friend
Zita GeoffroyTour Group Mom
Laura JordanWoman
Zachary UngerJeremiah - 8 Years Old
Lisa EmeryMrs. Pressman
Mihran SlougianJeremiah's Dad
Lynne TaylorJeremiah's Mom
Brian d'Arcy JamesChristopher Flynn
Leigha HancockYulia Karasov
Sarah QuinnYoung Mother
Jason BlajSupermarket Kid
David SiminsA Capella Singer
Brad WilsonA Capella Singer
Ryan McCartyA Capella Singer
Krishna ChoudharyA Capella Singer
Ricky JonesA Capella Singer
Thomas MerckensA Capella Singer
Alan Robert SouthworthA Capella Singer
Chris BronwellA Capella Singer
Chris PalermoA Capella Singer
Anthony CapersJeremiah's Buddy
Julia Faye FisherAgency Receptionist
Gameela WrightWoman in Adoption Agency
James P. AndersonBaxter Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)
Tina BenkoAndrea (uncredited)
Matthew BroadleyTwin Brother (uncredited)
Vanessa CarterQuest Student (uncredited)
Alix CrossQuest Student (uncredited)
Jonathon CulverQuest Student (uncredited)
Giullian Yao GioielloPrinceton Applicant (uncredited)
Brandon Lee HarrisOffice Assistant (uncredited)
Alice LitvakTwin Sister (uncredited)
Nicole MaggioLacrosse Girl (uncredited)
Alexis MolnarPrinceton College Applicant (uncredited)